Monday, December 29, 2014

Spring 2015_Adventure Two: What is place, whose place is it, and whose place is it not?




By the time you arrive to this adventure, you will have begun to unpack the importance of place.  In particular, you will have been asked to think about the university, your specific college, and your city, and you will, perhaps more importantly have been asked to think about what defines a community of need and a community of promise.  

The fundamental question is, why is place important?  This exercise will help you further the journey down the road, and it will also help you understand how your place needs YOU, and people like you, to make it better.

Here are the words to Clint Smith's Spoken Word piece titled Place Matters, the one in the video above.  Play it again, but this time scroll down here to read the words.  Then, respond to the prompt below.

As a child, my father would tell me stories of ancient Egyptian warriors
Traveling for endless days and nights across infinite desert plains
Showing signs of endurance and bravery I could only dream of emulating.
He would tell me
That, upon their return home, these warriors would be welcomed with a feast
Worthy of their bravery on the battlefield.
Years later, as a teacher in ? Washington D.C.,
I do now find myself traversing a desert,
Though it is not the one I envisioned.

A food desert
Is categorized as a poor urban area where residents cannot afford
Or are not given access access to healthy foods and grocery stores.
Every day, at 2:45,
I watch my students hop onto this leaking submarine of a school bus,
Every block bringing them deeper into an ocean where the only fish they find are fried,
Where fruits and vegetables just can't be found because there are no grocery stores here;
Just liquor stores and Popeye's,
Dunkin' Donuts, and 7-11's, children born into a neighborhood that fills more pollution than solution.
It is then I realize
That I am not too far from the deserts I once dreamed of.

See whether Anacostia or the Sahara, it doesn't make much difference because the [whole foods?].
Southeast D.C. is no different than the Serengeti
To them, brown-skinned little boys like my students are nothing more than walking cacti.
Just a piece of scenery, this world who taught everyone to stay awake.

Brianna
Literally has a landfill in her backyard
So she has a hard
Time convincing herself
The world then just thinks she's trash.
Restaurants come and dump the remains of food she'll never be able to afford
To eat three steps from her back door.

Jose
Eats fast food five days a week
Because his mother works three jobs to take care of six kids
And only sees her son when she arrives home from work
At the same time he's leaving for school.
He has gotten so big
That the excess fat ? his skin puts added pressure on his joints.
His knees are literally crumbling under the weight of this world.

Olivia
Watched her father shot two feet from her front porch.
She wants nothing more
Than to go outside and play at the park after school,
But gun violence has made a merry-go-round feel more like Russian Roulette.
So she doesn't go outside,
Simply eats any processed food from the cabinets
That will last long enough to prevent her from leaving the house too often.

These are my students,
My warriors,
Fighting a battle against an enemy they cannot clearly see.
These kings and queens,
Meant to feast not to fester,
But their zip code has already told them that their life expectancies are 30 years shorter than the county seven miles away.
I can see the faults of my own ancestry shaking in their eyes.
Diabetes and high blood pressure run through the roots of my family tree.
Heart disease is as much a part of my history as shackles and segregation.
So from my father's kidney transplant to Oliva's asthma,
These things are more than mere coincidence.
Both grew up in places more accustomed to gunshots than gardens.

So tell me place doesn't matter,
That the neighborhoods that are predominately healthy aren't the same ones that aren't predominantly wealthy.
Because when you're not choosing between buying your medicine and your groceries, health doesn't have to be a luxury,
Doesn't have to be an abstract concept that are presented in academic journals and policy briefs.

My students overcome more every day than I will in my lifetime.
They are the roses that grew from the concrete,
The budding oasis in the heart of the desert.
And their lives are worth far much more than the things that this world has fed them.

Answer the following prompts with no more than three sentences each.
  • Prompt One: Why do you think place matters?  
  • Prompt Two: What is "place" anyway?
  • Prompt Three: And who does it belong to?
  • Prompt Four: And who should it belong to?

Answers to these prompts are due at the beginning of Adventure Three.










15 comments:

  1. One: Place matters because it helps to shape the kind of person someone could become.
    Two: Place is a location relative to something else.
    Three: It can belong to anyone
    Four: It should belong to everyone equally

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1: Place matters because there are strata of communities that have different incomes. Houses of the same price are all in the same place so all the poor people are in the same place as are the rich.
    2. Where something is in relation to something else.
    3. Belonging is something we've made up. No one owns it.
    4. I guess if it were to belong to someone it should belong to those who work in that place.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think place matters because depending on where you are you will have different opportunities and people around you.

    it is a location on earth, state of mine, or a group of people in which you assoiciate with. in any of these places you can belong.

    it can belong to anyone that is there. it may be your's but someone elses at the same time.

    everyone should share and own these places equally and share the wealth in them

    ReplyDelete
  4. 1: Place matters because there are strata of communities that have different incomes. Houses of the same price are all in the same place so all the poor people are in the same place as are the rich.
    2. Where something is in relation to something else.
    3. Belonging is something we've made up. No one owns it.
    4. I guess if it were to belong to someone it should belong to those who work in that place.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Prompt 1: Place matters due to the fact that being in the wrong place at the wrong time can have a very bad effect. Place also matters because, like it said in the video, a seven mile difference in location can have a 30 year difference in life expectancy.
    Prompt 2: Place is a location on Earth, or a state of mind. It can be a descriptive term used to describe something in relation to something else.
    Prompt 3: It belongs to no one, yet everyone. it depends on how people think.
    Prompt 4: It should belong to anyone who wants it, not any one specific person.

    ReplyDelete
  6. 1: Place matters because society tends to put borders between different people and places.
    2: Place can be anywhere such as a certain location, certain people, or certain time.
    3: Place does not really belong to anyone, but people do claim.
    4: Place should belong to everyone, if it is to belong to anyone.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1. Place matters, because where you live can determine how you grow up and the opportunities you have. Where you live can determine who you are.
    2. Place is something in relation to something else, or somewhere in time.
    3. Place can belong to anyone who is occupying it.
    4. Place should belong to everyone who is occupying the space equally.

    ReplyDelete
  8. One: Place matters because it defines where you come from and who you are. While those aren't your only defining characteristics, they do help to shape who you are and who you will become.
    Two: Place isn't about just where you are from, it's about how you grow up and the different advantages and disadvantages your life involves.
    Three: Unfortunately, wealthier people do see more of the benefits of place. They have access to better food, environments, education, and much more that allows them to have better advantages.
    Four: Place should belong to everyone. All people have the right to healthcare, healthy food, safe and supported housing, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  9. One: Place matters because it is what defines your character. Your "place" has been filled with people and experiences that have helped shaped you into who you are today.
    Two: Place can be a physical, spiritual, or emotional state.
    Three: Place belongs to anyone who owns it.
    Four: Place should belong to everyone, for we should have a right to be anywhere we want and we shouldn't have people dominating certain places over us.

    ReplyDelete
  10. 1.Place matters because it is what makes you who you are. It could be race, background , religion, or anything. Place defines any of this.
    2.Place is relation to something else.
    3. It belongs to everyone because everything takes up space.
    4.It should belong to everyone

    ReplyDelete
  11. 1) Place plays a huge role in shaping an individual's characteristics, morals, and overall appearance.
    2) A place could be considered your location at a given time, or it could be a state of mind that someone experiences; like your "happy place".
    3) Places belong to everyone that want to belong to it.
    4) And places should belong to everyone and anyone that want to belong to it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 1: Place matters because not only can it impact you, but it can define who you are. Such as your character, background, culture, etc.
    2: Place can mean your home, where you're from, or where you feel most comfortable.
    3: A place can belong to anyone. I think anyone can belong and share a certain place.
    4: A place should belong to anyone and everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The government states that a place is definitively owned by someone, proved by official documents, pieces of paper, but a place never truly belongs to one person. People spend time in one place or another, but we never truly own it. We share it with the rest of humanity, nature, the universe surrendering it when we die. There are laws and regulations in order to keep peace between others so that they do not fight over it, but looking at the world we understand that each of us takes our turn inhabiting a place. No one could ever own a mind-set. People think differently and their thoughts and dreams are a unique place in itself that no one truly owns including the person encompassed in their mind. Place should be shared more equally. People should be more generous with the space they inhabit so that others can also benefit.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Place matters, but only because of the resources and opportunities available: the advantages and disadvantages. The people in the place that give help and support, infrastructure, accessibility of education and basic needs are much more important than a geographical location or mindset. No matter the geographical location or mindset, a person cannot thrive without others support and help, opportunities, and basic needs. “Place” cannot be tied down to the definition of “a point in space;” it could be a geographical location, but just as easily it could be a mindset. Some people are said to be far away when they daydream, that their mind is somewhere else.

    ReplyDelete
  15. 1. Place matters because it shapes who you are as a person, social imagination, we are who we are in part based on our social influences, where we live, our friends, the opportunities we have. Place shapes us into who we are today.
    2. Place can mean many things, the area you live in, the opportunities you have, your state of mind, support you receive are all examples of this 'place'.
    3. Place is a place for everyone depending on how they see 'place'
    4. This place should belong to everyone and not be confined to a certain group, it is a place for everyone.

    ReplyDelete